Student Is Denied License Because Tesla Has FSD / Too Many Safety Features

A user on Reddit recently had their daughter use their Tesla Model Y for her driving license test. Originally, they thought she passed the test and everything went swimmingly.

However, Arizona’s Department of Transportation (AZDOT) systems were down, so they were told to come back the next day to get her physical license. Easy enough, right?

FSD? No Licence

It turns out it's never that easy. The AZDOT tester thought that the daughter was using FSD during the driving portion of her exam and ended up denying her license. Now, while we know FSD sometimes drives like a teen driver, it turns out that Theduke432’s Model Y didn’t even have FSD. After explaining the situation to the Department of Vehicles, AZDOT backtracked.

they have too many safety features.

They found another reason to deny the license – insufficient use of the brake pedal. AZDOT thought that because the daughter didn’t use the brake pedal – as Teslas, like most EVs, primarily rely upon regenerative braking to slow the vehicle down – AZDOT didn’t think she could drive a non-Tesla.

The employee in question said they may have to ban Teslas from taking the road test – because they have too many safety features.

“Too Many Safety Features”

It seems like AZDOT thought the student driver may have had some unfair advantages, but we checked their online policy, and there’s nothing that says you can’t use a Tesla or a vehicle with regenerative braking on driving tests. In fact, we’re pretty sure if the daughter showed up with a hybrid, which also has regenerative braking, this wouldn’t have been an issue. We’re pretty sure this is a case of Tesla’s being featured in headlines praising its FSD features.

The employee in question said they may have to ban Teslas from taking the road test – because they have too many safety features. Now, the Model Y is one of the, if not the safest vehicle in the world, so we can at least agree with AZDOT on that.

The fact is, Teslas are easier and safer to drive, but that’s a good thing. Just like an automatic car is easier to drive than a standard shift.

In recent Teslas, any produced after January 2024, Tesla doesn’t even offer any regenerative brake settings. There’s a single option for everyone, which increases regen and improves efficiency. The same holds true for stopping mode, only Hold is available for newer vehicles, while older ones still have the option to choose between creep (like an automatic car, where it inches forward when you let go of the brake pedal) and roll (which mimics a standard vehicle and the car can roll forward or back when you don’t have your foot on the brake pedal).

Ban Teslas, All EVs?

We don’t think that it is AZDOT’s place to tell people that they are incapable of driving a vehicle with regular braking while testing in a Tesla. AZDOT will allow people to drive with automatic transmissions – does that mean that everyone has to test with a manual transmission?

While we’re on that subject, why don’t we test and make sure that everyone knows how to crank their car? Oh, your car doesn’t have a crank. Guess you can’t get a driver’s license. When you look at it after taking a step back, this seems silly and nonsensical. EVs are the future, and if the driver is a competent driver of a road-legal vehicle that they came to test in, there should be no reason to fail them.

Turns out that after the incident, Theduke432 got a call from AZDOT stating that their daughter can have her driver’s license – but that AZDOT will be re-evaluating their test going forward. We look forward to seeing whether AZDOT brings out the horse and buggy for their test, or if they realize that regenerative braking is on a large percentage of vehicles on the road today.

Consider using our referral code (nuno84363) to help support our site and get $1,000 off your Tesla.